The Six Wives of Henry Lefay

Elisha Cuthbert

Barbara 'Barbie' Lefay

Tim Allen

Henry Lefay

Jenna Elfman

Ophelia

Andie MacDowell

Kate

Lindsay Sloane

Autumn

Jenna Dewan

Sarah Jane

Paz Vega

Veronica

Edward Herrmann

John Goodenough

S. Epatha Merkerson

Effa

Larry Miller

Lipschutz

Chris Klein

Stevie

Eric Christian Olsen

Lloyd

Barbara Barrie

Mae

Peter Kybart

Minister

Lynne Lipton

Woman at Casket

William Huntley

Pirate

Annie O'Sullivan

Nurse

Starla Benford

Assistant

Jheri Cavitt

Bikini Beach Girl (uncredited)

John Farrer

Priest (uncredited)

Connor Fox

Best Man (uncredited)

Rebecca Guzman

Bridesmaid (uncredited)

James Howarth

The Naked Sombrero Guy (uncredited)

Klaudia Ann Jaworski

Hot Beach Girl (uncredited)

Michael James Kelly

Guitar Player (uncredited)

Monica McCarthy

Maid of Honor (uncredited)